e
ernard
Mar 01, 2012

What kind of problems could be caused by a massive solar flare?

There was a pretty major solar flare a month or two ago, but I didn't hear of any significant problems it caused. I remember that there was concern that it could damage satellites, and the astronauts on the ISS went into a heavily shielded area to be safe. So I understand that satellites are at risk in such an event, but what about down here on terra firma? What kind of problems would it likely cause, and is there anything we can do about it?

jimlynch
03/02/2012
Here's a good background article on solar flares. Everything you need to know about them.

Solar flares: everything you need to know
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/science/space/9097587/Solar-flares-everything...

"A solar flare is a large explosion of magnetic energy in the Sun’s atmosphere which causes an intense burst of increased brightness. They cannot be detected by the naked eye from the surface of the earth but can be observed through telescopes, space x-rays and thermal imaging equipment.

The amount of energy released by a flare can be equivalent to millions of 100-megaton hydrogen bombs exploding at the same time – ten million times greater than that released by a volcanic eruption.

Often lasting just a few minutes, solar flares heat material to many millions of degrees and produce a burst of radiation across the electromagnetic spectrum, including from radio waves to x-rays and gamma rays. "
d
dblacharski
03/02/2012
Wow, great answer. Mom, was right, you do learn something new every day. I remember reading about a massive event in the 1800s, and the telegraph operators were actually burning their hands on their, er, what ever you call the tappy-tappy things they used. I guess this was due to the inducement of current in long wires that JHourcle mentioned. I've read that in Indianapolis, Indiana, the aurora borealis was visible during the 1800s event to the extent that one could look SOUTH to see it. I wouldn't want to risk the power grid to see that, but I have to admit it would be one heck of a consolation prize.
J
JHourcle
03/02/2012

You're asking the wrong question.  Flares themselves are mostly energy, and when they're called 'flares', they tend to be optical wavelengths or lower (EUV, x-ray, etc.), and it's moving at the speed of light, so there's really nothing you can do to protect yourself against them as we don't have any sort of warning.  They *can* damage satellites, particularly those that are directly solar observing (a couple of years ago, one of the GOES SXI telescopes was in the middle of commissioning, taking a 25 min exposure during a flare)

 

The question you should be asking is about solar activity in general, as flares are often the precursor of other types of activity.  Radio Bursts are similar to flares, but in lower frequencies; the main issue with them is that they're effectively noise, so if they're at the GPS frequencies, or something else that uses a rather weak signal, you can't hear it.  So a few years back (2006? 2007?), there was a day when GPS was effectively useless.

 

You also have Solar Energetic Particle (SEP) events, where you have highly energetic particles which can do nasty things to electronics and people in space.  Our atmosphere and magetic field shields us from most of it, but the way the magnetic field shields us, it actually concentrates things at the poles, which is why some airlines won't fly the trans-polar flights during periods of high solar activity.  For humans in space without the atmosphere, strong enough storms could kill them from radiation.  For satellites, it can cause damage to solar panels or electronics or more subtle things like flipping bits in memory.

 

You also have Coronal Mass Ejections (CME), which are larger clouds of material ... they're slowing moving, so we might have time to do something to protect against them, but the big problems is that they often have a magnetic charge, and depending on the direction of if, it can partially cancel out the earth's magnetic field.   It can also induce current in long wires, which if strong enough can cause damage to the power grid, particularly at high latitudes.

 

You can get more information on frequency of these events from NOAA's Space Weather Prediction Center: http://www.swpc.noaa.gov/NOAAscales/ ; note that a 'cycle' in this context is about 11 years.

 

Disclaimer : I'm not a solar physicist, but I do IT support for them.  If you want an authoritiative answer, ask Alex Young : http://www.thesuntoday.org/

Answer this